1. How can I create a star list when so much details are needed in order to connect each star with its possible meanings and then to the G glyphs? Let us ignore this troublesome question and just move on. Instead of the alphabetical order in my book on astronomy I will use the right ascension values:
Allen: "... [γ] erroneously placed by Tycho in Pisces, marks the extreme tip of the Horse's wing, so that its name Algenib has been considered as derived from Al Janāh, the Wing, but it probably is from Al Janb, the Side. It has sometimes been written Algemo. Al Birūni quoted it, with δ (α Andromedae), as Al Fargh al Thāni, the Second, or Lower, Spout, i.e. of the Bucket. This also is the title of the 25th manzil, but appears in Professor Whitney's list as Al Fargh al Mu'hir, the Rear Spout, and in Smyth's as Al Fargu ..."
However, the list of manazil in Wikipedia has no Fargh. Neither is Algenib straight above any part of the current Aquarius constellation. But there once was a bucket here, Allen: "The Arabs knew the familiar quadrangle [the Pegasus Square] as Al Dalw, the Water-Bucket, the Amphora of some Latin imitator, which generally was used for the Urn in Aquarius; and the Arabian astronomers followed Ptolemy in Al Faras al Thānī, the Second Horse, which Bayer turned into Alpheras; Chilmead, into Alfaras Alathem, and La Lande into Alpharès." I cannot see any horse's wing among the glyphs above (and there were no horses on Easter Island at the time when the G tablet was created). Two horses are pictured both by Johann Bode and in the Urania's Mirror version:
The horses are drawn upside down and we therefore might think we need to turn the starchart 180º around in order to find which stars are where in these drawings. But such is not the case. Aquarius is below the pair of heads and the right ascension numbers are decreasing towards right. 'Sirrah or Alpheratz' is says at α Andromedae, the star inside the Andromeda constellation in the upper left corner, and Algenib must then be the great star in the wing below and somewhat to the left. After that we can easily find Sirrah and Algenib also in Bode's picture. |